Free Market Price Transparency and Price Competition
Stanley Feld M.D.,FACP,MACE
Physicians can take a leadership role in creating price transparency
leading to price competition.
An excellent example is the Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
Dr. Keith Smith and Dr.
Steven Lantier launched the Surgery Center of Oklahoma 15 years ago. I wrote
about the Center’s guaranteed online all-inclusive surgery prices six months
There are several innovative physician driven market driven pricing systems in the nation.
The Surery Center's price transparency is
catching on. It is leading to price competition, which in turn is leading to
reduced healthcare costs.
The Surgery Center of
Oklahoma’s online pricing is disrupting the lack of price transparency in their
“What we’ve discovered is health care really doesn’t cost that
much,” Dr. Smith said. “What people are being charged for is another matter
are paying a high premium for buying healthcare insurance. The healthcare
industry takes at least 40% off the top of healthcare premiums.
Systems inflate their prices for many reasons. Some insurance companies pay
more than others for hospital systems’ services. Hospital systems do not know
what the consumer’s insurance would pay when consumers come into the hospital
so they register the highest prices on the consumer’s bill.
systems try to charge as much as they can to collect as much as possible. The
pricing is not based on reality.
Surgery Center of Oklahoma started posting their prices online
about four years ago.
Click here to see the online prices at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
“When we first started we
thought we were about half the price of the hospitals,” Dr. Lantier remembers.
“Then we found out we’re less than half price.
Then we find out we’re a
sixth to an eighth of what their prices are. I can’t believe the average person
can afford health care at these prices.”
It is important to note that most physicians do not know what
hospital charges are.
The Surgery Center of Oklahoma has stated that they were founded on the simple principle of
price honesty and transparency. The Surgery Center of Oklahoma’s return on
investment and net profit is extremely healthy at the prices it charges.
The prices for procedures are
all-inclusive quotes and are guaranteed.
The result was to start a local price war.
The Surgery Center of Oklahoma is disruptive to the hospital pricing in its
community. This disruptive pricing is spreading across the nation. Consumers from
all over have come to the Surgery Center of Oklahoma because the price is
transparent and reasonable compared to hospital systems in their local area. One
specific example is.
“Matthew Gang, 22, tore his patella tendon, dislocating his
knee-cap playing basketball earlier this year.”
Mr. Gang is uninsured. He lives in California.
Surgery in his California community was going to cost him about $30,000.
The Surgery Center of Oklahoma Internet
price was $5,700.
Matthew and his father Tom Gang flew from
California to Oklahoma for surgery.
“It was well worth it,” Tom Gang said. “I need a rotator cuff
surgery right now. I’m thinking about flying out there and having my surgery
because it was such a positive experience for us.”
Other Oklahoma medical and surgical
facilities have started joining Surgery Center of Oklahoma in posting prices
and becoming price transparent. Hospital systems are realizing they will have
to compete with low price transparent prices to attract patients.
Surgery Center of Oklahoma does accept
private insurance, but the Center does not accept Medicaid or Medicare.
“Dr. Smith said federal Medicare regulations would not allow for
their online price menu.
“They have avoided government regulation and control in that area
by choosing not to accept Medicaid or Medicare payments”.
order to circumvent the Medicare guidelines the Kempton Group’s website, a
third party administrator, posts prices for other providers in the area.
The difference in billed prices are
staggering between Mercy Hospital in OKC, Intergris Baptist Medical Center and
OU Medical Center vs. Surgery Center of Oklahoma. The prices are,
- Mercy Hospital charged $16, 244 for a breast biopsy; the procedure
will cost $3,500 at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
- OU Medical Center billed $20,456 for the open repair of a
fracture; the procedure will cost $4,855 at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
- OU Medical Center billed $21,556 for a gall bladder removal
surgery; the procedure will cost $5,865 at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
- OU Medical Center billed $23,934 for an ankle arthroscopy; the
procedure will cost $3,740 at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
- Integris Baptist billed $37,174 for a hysterectomy; the surgery
costs $8,000 at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.
However, prices may be dropping elsewhere because of the
transparency at Surgery Center of Oklahoma.”
am writing about the Surgery Center of Oklahoma for the second time for two
than crying about the issue of the lack of price transparency as Dr. Uwe
Reinhardt did in my last post, someone is actually doing something about it. It
is causing hospital systems and large clinics to lower prices and make them
“Second, the government should not be in the
way. President Obama has provided some
non-transparent favors to hospital systems that are forcing physicians to be
employed by hospitals.
provision buried in Obamacare effectively prohibits doctors from
starting their own hospitals or expanding the hospitals they already own, which
has been widely interpreted as a give-away to the American Hospital
As patients are starting to demand price
matching, some hospitals are giving in.
“Hospitals are having to match our prices because patients are
printing their prices and holding that in one hand and holding a ticket to
Oklahoma City in the other hand and asking that hospital to step up,” Dr. Smith
said. “So we’re actually causing a deflationary effect on pricing all over the
The economics are simple even though
hospital systems deny it. One only has to recall the multiple million dollar
salaries of hospital CEOs as well as other hospital administrator salaries to
understand the hospital systems’ desires for less transparency.
Physicians are waking up and realizing
they are not the main cause of escalating costs. The Surgery Center of Oklahoma
is a wonderful example of a price transparent organization that is doing
something to force price competition.
It is clear. The government is not going
to create price transparency.
Physicians and patients must drive the adoption of a free market
Consumers must drive price transparency.
The opinions expressed in the blog “Repairing The Healthcare System” are, mine and mine alone
Please have a friend subscribe