The House Republicans finally got their act together and passed their version of the Obamacare repeal and replace act. It seems that many representatives do not trust Paul Ryan, Tom Price and President Donald Trump.
The Republican house version of the bill does not repeal and replace Obamacare completely.
The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) permitted Kathleen Sibelius, the Secretary of HHS, to issue regulations to administer the act at her discretion. Many of her regulations were destructive to the healthcare system.
Tom Price, the new Secretary of HSS can eliminate many of these destructive regulations. The goal of the Obama administration’s regulations was to cause the healthcare system to fail and be replaced not by free market principals but by a single party payer system.
Her regulations were designed to eliminate any modicum of free choice for patients and physicians.
Tom Price’s actions and regulation eliminations should complete the repeal and replacement of Obamacare.
President Obama ignored the fact that a single party payer system would be destined to bankrupt the country. His plan was to get the health care insurance industry out of the healthcare picture.
The defect in his logic was that the government would have to continue to outsource the administrative services to the healthcare insurance industry. The government now outsources the administrative services for Medicare and Medicaid.
The government then lies to the public declaring that its overhead is only 2.5% while the healthcare insurance industry takes 30% for services that are charged as direct patient care.
The healthcare insurance industry would continue to rip off the healthcare system in a single party payer system for all.
The completion of the repeal and replace act will be done as promised by Ryan, Price and Trump in three stages.
As soon as the house bill is passed the House Democrats came out with their talking points criticizing the act. These talking points had little substance and no compelling evidence. They only declared that the legislation was terrible without any explanation of why it was terrible.
They just said 20 million people are going to lose their insurance coverage. The Republican health care act is going to kill people.
The talking points are mostly lies.
A recent study had reported that Obamacare has cost 80,000 people to die.
“Democrat’s immediately made the accusation that the GOP “repeal and replace” bill will kill Americans. It seems that Obamacare has already done that.”
In a previous blog I pointed out that more people have lost insurance in the individual market that have gained insurance from Obamacare’s health insurance exchanges.
Fourteen million lost insurance in the individual market in 2009 and at most 8 million gained insurance through Obamacare’s health insurance exchanges.
The 20 million new insured comes from the 12 million new people receiving healthcare insurance through Medicaid.
“Quoting Oren Cass over at National Review, it turns out that fewer people – not more people – had health insurance after Obamacare. The only increase in “coverage” was Medicaid, but, sadly, it turns out that Medicaid kills people. It’s better to have no medical insurance at all.”
Researchers have found that in 2015 Medicaid patients experienced worse outcomes than similar uninsured Medicaid eligible patients.
“Public-health data from the Centers for Disease Control confirm… [that had mortality continued to decline during ACA implementation in 2014 and 2015 at the same rate as during the 2000-13 period, 80,000 fewer Americans would have died in 2015 alone.”
The Democrats are using the typical progressive tactic of creating a lie. Many people died because of Obamacare but the Democrats threaten that the Republican bill will cost many lives. It diverts attention from the Democrats’ failure with Obamacare.
This is fear mongering for the progressives’ political gain.
This is one of Sol Alinsky’s favorite tactics. One should do everything to marginalize opponents even if it needs to be done by lying.
“Democrats are hurting real people with their scary shrieking about death by Republican.”
The Democrats criticize without facts. The Democrats will lie about the effects of the bill without evidence. I would guess that many have not even read it.
One should expect nothing less from Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer.
The Democrats have even rolled out Jonathan Gruber, the MIT professor of economics and co-author of Obamacare, who infamously said, “the stupidity of the American voter” helped get the measure to become law.
This week Gruber blamed President Trump for Obamacare’s failure on one of the Sunday news programs.
“Whose fault is this (rising premium costs)?” Gruber asked on “Fox News Sunday.” “Since President Trump has been elected … premiums are going up and insurers are exiting.”
This is total nonsense.
Jonathan Gruber still thinks Americans are stupid. However he has no credibility with the American public. Therefore his opinion has no impact on the discussion about the new bill.
Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer’s lack of credibility with the American public does not seem to bother them.
Every lie they tell decreases their credibility even further.
Nancy Pelosi said, “the new Obamacare repeal bill is a ‘a very sad, deadly joke’
This is the same woman who said we will not know what is in the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) until it is passed.
What is so deadly about it? She does not explain her statement. She figures the media is the message. The media will carry the message for her.
Chuck Schumer’s quote was even worse. He said, “Senate GOP should toss House healthcare bill ‘out the window’”
He called on Senate Republicans,
“To avoid following the lead of their colleagues in the House and to work on a bipartisan basis on healthcare reform rather than pushing for repeal of the Affordable Care Act.”
He is trying to save President Obama’s legacy Obamacare. Obamacare is an unmitigated disaster. It is beyond saving.
It was a poorly constructed healthcare bill aimed at giving big government total control of the healthcare system. President Obama totally ignores the fact that Americans did not want it, have not joined it. He felt he clearly know what is best for America.
He goal was to get it passed by the partisan vote. President Obama lied to Americans and lied to his party members.
Obamacare is unsustainable economically to America and is in the process of destroying the economy.
Chuck Schumer said, “Trumpcare is a giant, broken promise to working people, the hard-working people of this great country of ours.“
It would be valid if Chuck Schumer could prove his statement.
President Obama broke his promise to the working people, the hard working people of this great country of ours, when he said, “ If you like your doctor you can keep your doctor and if you like your insurance you can keep your insurance.”
Chuck Schumer did not see it then and he does not see Obamacare’s failure now.
I suggest that Chuck Schumer read the Republican bill carefully before he makes his false statements.
Clearly, he was dead wrong in his judgment about Obamacare
If he read the Obamacare law carefully and voted for doing the right thing, America’s healthcare system might not be in the mess it is in.
The opinions expressed in the blog “Repairing The Healthcare System” is, mine and mine alone.
All Rights Reserved © 2006 – 2017 “Repairing The Healthcare System” Stanley Feld M.D.,FACP,MACE
Please have a friend subscribe