President Obama Tries To Bully The Supreme Court
Stanley Feld M.D.,FACP,MACE
President Obama attacks his opponents, marginalizes them, throws them under a bus, lies, ignores reality, or bullies them.
The reality about Obamacare is that none of the stakeholders like it.
It is causing states with State Health Insurance Exchanges to go deeper in debt.
The government has been forced to create 37 Federal Health Insurance Exchanges. Premiums are skyrocketing because of poor enrollment and demographic distribution. Only people with pre-existing illnesses or those receiving subsidies are joining.
Premiums are now unaffordable even applicants receiving subsidies.
Obamacare is driving corporations providing healthcare insurance for their employees to figure out how to avoid providing healthcare insurance and penalties.
The government has provided waivers for companies such as McDonalds, Burger King and 1300 other companies to not participate in Obamacare.
Obamacare has tried to take away Medicaid subsidies from states that did not start a State Health Insurance Exchange and would not expand Medicaid. The Supreme Court stopped that two years ago.
Obamacare has driven physicians into hospital employment. Many physicians are unhappy and less productive working for hospitals themselves.
Many physicians have retired early because of Obamacare. This is a bad sign in light of our present physician shortage.
Obamacare has created incentives for hospitals to create Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).
Logically ACOs cannot work because they shift financial risk for patients on to physicians and hospitals and away rom the healthcare insurance industry.
Hospitals and physicians are finally starting to realize the risk and are dropping out of the ACO programs.
Obamacare has spent over one billion dollars for a web site that is still not fully functional.
The promise of universal healthcare coverage has resulted in more people being uninsured than before Obamacare was passed. Only 9 million people are signed up and 6.4 million receive subsidies.
The original prediction in 2009 for 2015 was 17 million participants.
The expanded Medicaid program in 14 states is experiencing severe physician shortages and financial problems.
Obamacare patients and Medicaid and Medicare patients are starting to experience limitations on access to care and rationing of care.
I am only naming a few of the many problems Obamacare has created.
Yet with all these defects and failures President Obama has the gall to say,
“There's something deeply cynical about the ceaseless partisan attempts to roll back progress.”
"I understand people being skeptical or worried before the law was passed and there was no reality to examine. But now that we can see millions of people having health care—and all the bad things that were predicted didn't happen—you'd think it was time to move on."
Obamacare is not working despite President Obama’s claims.
I think it is time to move away from Obamacare and in another direction.
This week President Obama did another astonishing thing. It reveals his consistent disrespect for the constitution and the separation of powers.
He has tried to intimidate the Supreme Court to rule in favor of Obamacare with his personal attack on the court and its upcoming decision in King vs. Burwell.
“The law provides for subsidies only for policies purchased on exchanges "established by the state", inserted in the law as an inducement to states to set up exchanges.”
Congress limited the subsidies to State Health Insurance Exchanges to encourage the states to set up their own exchanges. Thirty-seven states saw the trap that President Obama was setting for them and refused to cooperate.
The IRS, operating under the direction of President Obama, tried to “fix” the law by permitting federal exchange to provide subsidies.
The infamous Dr. Jonathan Gruber, a principle framer of Obamacare, who was paid by the Obama administration $375,000 for his consultations with the White House staff, said the exclusivity of state exchanges rewarding subsidies was put into the law to induce states to set up exchanges.
Dr. Gruber, a healthcare economist, also said the law would have not passed if the public was not so stupid and could recognize the lack of transparency of the law.
President Obama said at the time of the scandal that he did not know Dr. Gruber. President Obama said Jonathan Gruber played a minor role in the construction of Obamacare.
During the last month President Obama has used the traditional media to try to convince the Supreme Court and the American people that congress really meant to give the State Exchanges and the Federal Exchanges to ability to provide insurance subsidies.
Article after article was published confirming that what the law meant to say was both State and Federal Exchanges had the ability to provide subsidies. This was morally the right thing to do.
President Obama said this week. “That we have an obligation to put ourselves in our neighbor’s shoes, and to see the common humanity in each other.”
First of all congress didn’t write the law. It should have and it should have been bipartisan. Most Democratic congressmen who voted for Obamacare didn’t even read the law.
The IRS has no authority to change the letter of the law with a regulation.
The law as written should be the law. The Obama administration overstepped its constitutional limits. If the law is wrong, congress should amend the words to include subsidies for federal exchanges also.
Obamacare is a terrible law. It is distorting and destroying our already dysfunctional healthcare system. The Republican dominated House and Senate are not going to change a law that is self destructing, if the Supreme Court favors King and the letter of the law.
Since President Obama’s traditional media campaign has been a flop, he has personally gone after the Supreme Court. He tried to intimate it by challenging its integrity.
President Obama said, “Frankly, the Supreme Court should not have taken up the lawsuit challenging Obamacare subsidies.”
Who is he to decide which cases the Supreme Court should take up?
President Obama continued,“There is no reason why the existing Federal Health Insurance Exchanges should be overturned through a Supreme Court case,”
President Obama is preparing the country to be angry at the Supreme Court if the Supreme Court rules in favor of King.
President Obama is disregarding the notion that the Supreme Court is interpreting and upholding the constitution, a concept he frequently ignores.
“I think it’s important for us to go ahead and assume that the Supreme Court is going to do what most legal scholars who've looked at this would expect them to do.”
This statement is both a lie and a veiled threat to the court.
“Elena Kagan recently wrote in another case that, "This Court has no roving license, in even ordinary cases of statutory interpretation, to disregard clear language simply on the view that (in [the IRS’s] words) Congress 'must have intended' something broader."
During oral arguments in March, Justice Antonin Scalia suggested Congress could step in and fix the problem.
“Congress just adjusts, enacts a statute. It would take care of the problem. It happens all the time,” he said. “Why is that not going to happen here?”
President Obama did say there was one way to resolve the dispute over the law: “Congress could fix this whole thing with a one-sentence provision.”
President Obama said, “He is puzzled by the legal challenges against his signature healthcare law, arguing there is ample evidence that the system is working.
“Fortunately, there's no reason to have to do it. It doesn't need fixing,”
President Obama keeps harping on the same lies. He believes if you tell a lie enough times it becomes the truth.
President Obama said, “Part of what's bizarre about this whole thing is, we haven't had a lot of conversation about the horrors of ObamaCare because none of them have come to pass.”
There has been limited conversation about the horrors of Obamacare in the media because President Obama and the traditional media have limited the conversation
President Obama cannot bully the Supreme Court into not of upholding the constitution and it obligation to interpret the constitution accurately.
The opinions expressed in the blog “Repairing The Healthcare System” are, mine and mine alone
Please have a friend subscribe